skip to main content

Great Transitions: The Origin Of Tetrapods

20 minutes

(Describer) In an animation, a blue and green lizard with a head like an arrow walks on four legs around a white screen, then freezes. Title: HHMI – BioInteractive.

[roars]

(Describer) A tiger jumps up in slow-motion.

(Describer) A herd of wildebeests crosses a river, and an iguana flicks its tongue.

(male narrator) Our planet is teeming with many kinds of animal life,

(Describer) A snake curls over rocks.

including groups with defining structures, such as the four legs of land animals,

(Describer) ...like furry camels.

the feathered wings of birds,

(Describer) ...like a tiny hummingbird.

and the dexterous hands of primates.

(Describer) ...like a squirrel monkey with its fingers and toes around branches.

Understanding the origins of these structures and of the groups that possess them, has long been a central quest of biology.

(Describer) A lizard moves one eye.

Charles Darwin asserted that each kind of animal must have evolved from preexisting, earlier kinds of animals that lacked those structures.

(Describer) He studies an armadillo shell.

He boldly predicted that buried in the crust of the earth, were animals that connected one major group to another.

(Describer) He draws branches.

Such transitional fossils would be intermediate in form between earlier and later groups.

(Describer) Neil Shubin, University of Chicago:

What made Darwin's prediction so bold, was when he stated it, in the Origin of Species, no such fossils had been found. His critics immediately latched on to the admission that transitional animals are somehow missing from the fossil record. Over the decades, it's become a talking point for those with closed minds to the science of evolution.

(Describer) Two men study a large rock.

But, in fact, since Darwin, paleontologists have unearthed hundreds of transitional creatures that have enabled us to reconstruct the origins of many groups.

(Describer) Long insect wings are printed in stone.

And even so, searching for such fossils remains a challenging adventure. Finding the right one can change the way we think about the origins of living creatures.

(Describer) Title: Great Transitions – The Origin of Tetrapods. Lines like Darwin drew branch off from the letter G. Shubin:

For me, paleontology has always been about filling gaps in the story of life. One of the biggest ones was understanding the origin of animal limbs with fingers and toes. Paired limbs are a feature of many animals.

(Describer) Horses gallop.

But there's little at first that suggests the limbs of different species are related.

(Describer) A frog jumps.

On frogs, they're springy. On elephants, not so much.

(Describer) An eagle takes off from a tree.

They're feathered on eagles, not on bats.

(Describer) A furry lemur crouches on a rock.

But inside the limbs of mammals, amphibians, reptiles, and birds, one finds a common architecture.

(Describer) A golden brown dog leaps from a car into a field.

Here's a dog. Dogs run and jump.

(Describer) Shubin sits with different skeletons.

What do you have? One bone, two bones, little bones, and then digits:

(Describer) He points down a leg.

the equivalents of the fingers or toes.

(Describer) He picks up a bird skeleton.

And, of course, here's a bird--it flies. It's limb has been modified into a wing and it has one bone,

(Describer) For the wings...

two bones, lots of bones, and then digits. The amazing fact is every four-limbed animal walking the earth today has this fundamental pattern of one bone, two bones, little bones, fingers.

(Describer) ...like in a human.

That pattern suggest a connection between these very different groups of animals.

(Describer) ...like cats and alligators.

And it's not the only feature they share. They also will have a backbone-- they're vertebrates. The history of vertebrates has been captured in rock we can accurately date.

(Describer) In an animation...

Fossils reveal when each animal group first emerged.

(Describer) Fossils appear underground.

The youngest group is the birds.

(Describer) Further down...

Go further back and you'll find the first mammals and then the first reptiles and the first amphibians. And then you get to 370 million years ago. Suddenly, there are no four-limbed creatures, or tetrapods, anywhere to be found. Where the first tetrapods came from has always been a great mystery of biology. It's not like there weren't animals or vertebrates around 400 million years ago, there were. But they were all...fish.

(Describer) They're shown deeper in the ground.

Did four-legged animals come from fish? Fish might seem unlikely candidates to be the earliest ancestors of frogs, horses, and humans. They don't even have limbs. They have fins. Despite their different external appearances, there are revealing similarities. First, fish and tetrapods are vertebrates. And early in life, when they are embryos, they look remarkably similar. Finally, DNA analysis shows that fish are tetrapods' closest relatives. All of this suggests four-legged animals did indeed come from fish. But how did a fish with fins give rise to tetrapods with four legs?

(Describer) A man and boy look into an aquarium.

As a scientist, I wanted to find fossils that could help answer that question. I knew it wasn't going to be easy. The world is big, the earth giant, and fossils tiny. How do you find those things? We run through a checklist. We look for rocks of the right age. For the origin of dinosaurs, there's one age of rock. For the origin of land-living creatures, another age. Then you look for rocks of the right type, the kinds of rocks that are likely to hold fossils.

(Describer) In an animation, a lizard stands in water.

Many things must happen for an animal to be fossilized. It has to be in the kind of setting where sediments form. Soon after dying, it has to be buried before its remains are ravaged by decay, weather, or scavengers.

(Describer) It's buried.

The dirt and mud burying it has to harden sufficiently to protect what's left for thousands or millions of years.

(Describer) Dirt builds up, then breaks down.

After which, something, say erosion has to bring the embedded remains to the surface. And then someone who cares about such things, like me or my longtime colleague Ted Dashler, has to wander by and find it. The fossils I wanted to find existed in the Devonian Era, between 365 and 385 million years ago.

(Describer) They study a map.

Where could we find the right rocks from that era?

(Describer) Sitting at a desk...

I remember sitting in the office. We were bantering about something geological. We had a college textbook.

(Describer) Evolution of the Earth.

We were just thumbing through the diagrams and boom, there was this figure that changed our lives.

(Describer) With Daschler...

I remember seeing that and saying to myself, "This is what we're looking for." A map of North America highlighted three areas of Devonian rock just the right type to hold fossil fish moving onto land. Two of those areas had already been worked on, so we focused on the third, the Canadian Arctic. My heart was racing when I saw that. I'm sure yours was too. No paleontologist had worked on that, expressly looking for early tetrapods. Then you dug out aerial photos. That's when I got kinda terrified.

(Describer) They look at one of mountains and snow.

[both laughing]

I thought, "You've gotta be kidding me." Look at all this snow. How do you work there?

(Describer) A flashlight is turned on and a rifle is packed. The two men get into a small plane, which taxis, and takes off.

[engines growl]

The arctic presents some unusual challenges.

(Describer) Shubin looks out a window.

You're far from help. You have to bring everything. You have to move fast because the season is short. You don't want to be there when the weather turns.

(Describer) They approach flat land with streaks of snow on hills around it. A helicopter flies lower, and soon lands.

(Describer) Later, it lowers a large sack of supplies.

When the helicopter drops you off the first time, you say, "What am I doing here?"

(Describer) Snow falls around him.

You're thinking of polar bears. Everything white becomes a polar bear at first. The last thing on your mind are fossils.

(Describer) Tents dot the flat but rocky land.

It's hard to believe that this frozen terrain was once a warm, watery world, swimming with life. There's this huge disconnect between the present and past. What we see is a valley with rocks that are tilted and stacked on each other. That's not how it was historically. These valleys have been carved by glaciers that have moved back and forth. Those red and green rocks extended across the valley. They were straight. They weren't tilted.

(Describer) They straighten behind him.

Inside, the rocks tell us that this valley, 375 million years ago, was a giant floodplain. That floodplain was filled with rivers that swelled their banks and sometimes shrunk, but in those conditions formed swamps and streams of all different sizes. Inside those streams was diverse life...

(Describer) Animated fish swim underwater.

including, we suspected, a fish with features that would ultimately enable animals to walk on land.

(Describer) On a sandy floor, a fish walks on four short legs, moving its tail side-to-side.

Even if it had been there, could we find evidence buried on one of the nameless hillsides that had built up and eroded over the past 375 million years?

(Describer) A team of four men stand on an outcrop, and soon spread out.

So, how do you find fossils? I pick up a lot of stuff.

(Describer) He picks up something small.

Sometimes it's just a piece of rock. Sometimes it's bird poop. Sometimes it's a leaf. But occasionally, it's a jaw with teeth in it.

(Describer) He sees patterns on larger rocks.

You learn to differentiate white which is not bone from white which is bone, teeth, or scale. Then you apply that search image to other rocks. Here's another scale here that stands out.

(Describer) It's white and round.

Then we go, if you look around-- one right here. This is the underside of a skull. You never know where you're gonna hit it. That's why we keep on lookin'.

(Describer) Lying on the ground and walking, they pick at pieces on dirt and among flat rocks.

(Describer) One of them picks up an oblong piece the size of his fingernail. Later, snow covers the ground.

But that first expedition ended without finding what we had come for.

(Describer) The snow is gone as they hike over another rocky hill.

As our second trip drew to a close, we were still searching. Then, a bit before our scheduled departure, we had a real scare.

(Describer) A rifle lies nearby, and small flowers grow elsewhere.

The team had separated.

(Describer) A figure stands on a ridge.

Everybody needs to return back to camp by radio call.

(Describer) In camp, Shubin looks around.

"Any of you see Jason?" "No, I ain't seen Jason." Suddenly it became, "Where's Jason?" This is our youngest member. We were looking out for him. My heart was beginning to race. Then I hear footsteps outside the tent.

(Describer) A tent is unzipped.

There's Jason. His eyes are like globes. "I think I found it." Every pocket was burgeoning with bones. He's laying them out on the table. It's daylight 24 hours a day, so we ran to Jason's site. As we came to this bluff and looked down, we saw why Jason was excited. Beneath our feet, were fossil fishbones--fragments. Thousands of them. It was a whole aquarium of different species. It got better because, as we walked up the hill

(Describer) He does.

and followed that carpet of fragments, it stopped. Meaning it likely came from one layer. With luck, we'd find that layer and see what's inside.

(Describer) Snow covers again.

Hard as we tried, we couldn't discover what was buried in Jason's hill before we had to leave.

(Describer) Later, the land is viewed from a plane.

We kept coming back to it in following years to dig, chip, and search.

(Describer) Three of them pick together.

The second week of July, 2004 we're working in series in this hole, where my head is next to Farish's feet, and Farish's feet is next to Steve Gatesy. We're digging and Steve says, "Hey, what's this? " Ted and I ran over to see. What we saw...was this V here. It was covered with rock.

(Describer) He holds up a large, flat fossil.

(Describer) ...at one end.

As soon as we saw this V and saw these teeth, it became clear that this V we're seeing is the tip of a snout and that this was the snout of a flatheaded fish. It was sticking out of the rock. With luck, the rest of the creature would be encased in the rock.

(Describer) In a room, he holds it up.

And here it is.

(Describer) Title: Tiktaalik, the Inuit word for large freshwater fish.

What's wonderful is that we have pretty much the whole thing. And it's put together: the head is connected to the body. The body is connected to the fins. So we know that this fin comes from this body.

(Describer) It's in two pieces.

Put together, we see this creature's about four feet long. Some of the biggest were about nine feet long. What's really amazing is that this is an animal that Darwin would have predicted, a real mix of characteristics: a combination of fish-like and tetrapod-like features. Like a fish, it has scales on its back. It also has fins with fin rays. Like a tetrapod, it has a flat head with eyes on top. When we look inside the body,

(Describer) He turns it over.

we see these huge interlocking ribs that suggested that it had lungs. When you put the body and the head together,

(Describer) He does.

you see a neck where the head moved independently. It could use the neck to peer outside the water, find prey, and avoid predators. So, we've many bones of these animals, including this one which is a hip bone.

(Describer) He holds it up.

It reveals that the hind fins were already evolving into legs while these animals were living in water. I get excited when I see the front fins of Tiktaalik. Here's one from a larger specimen.

(Describer) ...like a sideways V.

You see the shoulder and some of the fin bones inside. You see a version of the one-bone, two-bone pattern that's inside our own arms. You have one bone, two bones, even a version of a wrist. Once those fins were strong enough to lift its body out of the water, a new frontier opened.

(Describer) In an animation, it crawls onto a beach.

Over millions of years, the two pairs of fins in fish-like Tiktaalik would lead to the two pairs of limbs in every tetrapod. What does this all mean? It means that our arms and legs are derived from the paired fins of our fishy ancestors. How fast did this transition happen? We know that Tiktaalik didn't exist in a vacuum. There are other creatures, other transitional fossils that are more fish-like and others more tetrapod-like. These creatures existed for over 15 million years. This means that this great transition from fish to tetrapod didn't happen in a single step, but happened gradually over time.

(Describer) Headlines appear.

The discovery of Tiktaalik made headlines because it is one of the earliest fossils that illuminate the transition from water to land.

(Describer) Soil is sifted at another site.

That's just one key transition fossils have shed light on.

(Describer) A bone is sketched.

One of the first was the evolution of birds from feathered dinosaurs. That's one of the best documented transitions in the story of life. What it and other well-studied examples tell us is that what first seemed to be huge leaps, are almost always products of a series of smaller evolutionary steps.

(Describer) A fossil is examined as a 3D computer model.

That's true for when our fish ancestors first came to land,

(Describer) A fossil is placed in a box.

when dinosaurs took to the air,

(Describer) A bird-like fossil is shown.

and when we first stood upright.

(Describer) Human bones are placed in order.

(male) ...had an ancestor who lived 3.2 million years ago.

(Describer) Titles: A film by Rob Whittlesey. Narrated by Neil Shubin, and based on his book Your Inner Fish. Executive Producer: Sean B. Carroll. Copyright Howard Hughes Medical Institute, 2014, all rights reserved. Funding to purchase and make this educational program accessible was provided by the U.S. Department of Education. Contact the Department of Education by telephone at 1-800-USA-LEARN, or online at www.ed.gov.

Funding to purchase and make this educational production accessible was provided by the U.S. Department of Education:

PH: 1-800-USA-LEARN (V) or WEB: www.ed.gov.

Transcript Options


Now Playing As: Captioned (English) (change)

Report a Problem

Charles Darwin once boldly predicted that buried deep in the earth are transitional fossils of creatures with intermediate features between ancestral animal groups and the modern animal groups. Since Darwin’s time, many transitional fossils have been discovered, and they provide crucial insights into the origin of key structures and the creatures that possess them. And University of Chicago paleontologist and award-winning author Neil Shubin provides a first-hand account of the painstaking search for the transitional fossil of Tiktaalik, a creature with a mix of features common to fish and four-legged animals.

Media Details

Runtime: 20 minutes

Great Transitions
Episode 1
20 minutes
Grade Level: 7 - 12
Great Transitions
Episode 2
19 minutes
Grade Level: 7 - 12
Great Transitions
Episode 3
20 minutes
Grade Level: 7 - 12

Viewer Comments

  • Tiny default profile photo
    Debra S. (Cottonwood Heights, UT)
    March 9th, 2016 at 02:42 PM

    This is a great film reviewing the fossil origin of tetrapods. Great for a biology class.