Caption It Yourself: Basic Guidelines for Busy Teachers, Families, and Others Who Shoot Their Own Video
What are Captions?
Captions (sometimes called “subtitles”) are the textual representation of a video's soundtrack. They are critical for viewers who are deaf or hard of hearing, and they are also a great tool for improving the reading and listening skills of others. Unlike subtitles, captions provide information such as sound effects and speaker identification.
If you upload video to the Web, and that video includes sound, you should always include a text alternative, such as captions. As an added bonus, since most captioning for the Web relies on text, providing captions for your videos will ensure that they are indexed by search engines more quickly and accurately, meaning your video will reach more people.
What's in a Caption?
A video's captions can transmit information such as:
- Offscreen narration
- On-screen dialogue
- Off-screen dialogue
- Unknown speaker
- Sound effects
The Benefits of Captions
- Captions help children with word identification, meaning, acquisition, and retention.
- Reading captions motivates viewers to read more and read more often.
- Captions can help children establish a systematic link between the written word and the spoken word.
- Pre-readers, by becoming familiar with captions, will have familiar signposts when they begin reading print-based material.
- Captioning has been related to higher comprehension skills when compared to viewers watching the same media without captions.
- Children who have a positive experience in reading will want to read; reading captions provides such an experience.
- Reading is a skill that requires practice, and practice in reading captions is practice with authentic text.
- Captions provide missing information for individuals who have difficulty processing speech and auditory components of the visual media (regardless of whether this difficulty is due to a hearing loss or a cognitive delay).
- Students often need assistance in learning content-relevant vocabulary (in biology, history, literature, and other subjects), and with captions they see both the terminology (printed word) and the visual image.
- Captioning is essential for children who are deaf and hard of hearing, can be very beneficial to those learning English as a second language, can help those with reading and literacy problems, and can help those who are learning to read.
Web-based Captioning/Subtitling Tools
- CaptionTube The latest CIY tool, CaptionTube has a clean (and simple) user interface and multi-language capability similar to many of the other resources identified below. It is slightly more integrated with YouTube than the others, and features a convenient export tool which allows you to e-mail the captions to a video’s owner (if you’re captioning for someone else) or download a .SUB or .SRT file. A CNET review of CaptionTube (which includes a couple video tutorials) provides a handy introduction to the service.
- dotSUB Allows people from around the world to create caption files in multiple languages for streaming videos. The dotSUB caption file can be exported to a SRT format for use with Subtitle Workshop. dotSUB Repair is an online script that replaces missing zeroes in SRT files exported from dotSUB. Use this tool to repair your SRT file before importing it to Subtitle Workshop.
- Subtitle Horse A tool for transcribing Flash videos online and exporting/converting a caption file in several different formats including the Timed Text XML format used by multiple video players including both the Adobe Flash and Microsoft Silverlight players. (Subtitle Horse was used to convert timing information for Equal Access in the Classroom's Timed Text captions)
- Easy YouTube Caption Creator A simple tool (designed for easy of use in mind) used to create captions for YouTube videos. Read about Easy YouTube Caption Creator on the Accessify blog or watch the Easy YouTube Caption Createor Screencast, also from Accessify.
Desktop Captioning/Subtitling Software
- Captionate A desktop application for captioning Flash videos. The caption output can be displayed using the JW FLV Media Player.
- CC For Flash (free) A Flash component that can be used to display captions for Flash video and audio content, as well as caption files saved in Apple’s Quicktime QText format.
- Jubler (free and open source) (Linux, Windows, and Mac) A Java-based tool for creating captions and subtitles in a variety of formats (installation can be tricky on Windows machines—Luckily, there is a step-by-step Jubler installation guide available.)
- CaptionMaker and MacCaption Video closed captioning for any Mac/PC digital workflow.
- MAGpie (free) (Windows and Mac) A tool for creating captions and audio description for multiple formats and media types.
- MovCaptioner (Mac only [Windows version in development]) Utilizes a GUI to create and synchronize captions in a number of popular formats. Single- and multi-user licenses available.
- Subtitle Workshop (free) (Windows only) The most complete, efficient and convenient freeware subtitle editing tool. It supports all the subtitle formats you need and has all the features you would want from a subtitle editing program.
Caption-Ready Video Hosting Providers
Google has launched its “auto caption” feature for new YouTube uploads by which text-to-speech software (of the type used by Google Voice) will attempt to automatically generate captions from a video’s soundtrack. If you’d like slightly more control over the content of your captions, Google has also implemented “automatic caption timing.” To use this feature, simply transcribe all of the words found in your video, and upload it as you would your SRT (timed) caption file (see below). The same text-to-speech algorithms used for “auto caption” will synchronize your transcribed text for you, eliminating the need to worry about timecodes. (Check YouTube help for more about these automatic features.)
However, the safest (and most accurate) bet would be to upload an SRT file with your video; once completed, this will enable a “CC” button on the video player interface and captioning will be turned on by default. YouTube has provided instructions for users interested in adding captions to their YouTube videos.
- If you create your captions with YouTube, you can download a SRT file for use in other applications:
- Click on the Sign in icon.
- Click on Creator Studio.
- Click on Edit and select Subtitles and CC.
- Click on English (Automatic) under Published.
- Click on Actions and select SRT.
- The file will download as "captions.srt."
- dotSUB Users can create, import, and export a SRT file with their video. Captions are displayed on the video during playback. Captions can be turned on or off using up and down arrow buttons.
How To CIY (Caption It Yourself™)
There are several free Web-based tools you can use to create captions for your streaming videos, all of which have their own particular features and limitations. For example, Overstream is an excellent tool for captioning Flash videos hosted on sites such as YouTube, Google Video, and MySpace. It is very easy to use and includes comprehensive tutorials. As is the case with most Flash video players, however, it does not provide options for modifying the placement, color, or style of the captions being displayed. Also, the captions can only be viewed using Overstream’s video player, which makes it impracticable for producers wishing to reach a larger audience by providing captions on the original hosting site (e.g., youtube.com). To get around this limitation it will be necessary to either “burn” the captions on to the video or to use a caption-ready Flash player such as the Google Video player or the JW Media Player.
If you’d prefer to create the caption files on your computer rather than over the Internet, you can download and install any one of a number of desktop captioning/subtitling programs that offer options to create and export caption files for many different players and formats. One such program, MAGpie, will allow you to create both a caption file as well as a description soundtrack (also known as an audio description soundtrack), which can be incorporated with your video to make it accessible to viewers who are blind or visually impaired. (Remember, you should always try to make your content accessible to all viewers.) A technical look at MAGpie is beyond the scope of this basic introduction to “do-it-yourself captioning,” but you can check out the extensive and easy-to-follow MAGpie documentation at NCAM’s Web site.
The DCMP staff has created tutorials on Providing Captions for Flash-based Video [PDF] as well as on how to use Google Video in the Classroom [PDF] and how to provide Equal Access in the Classroom. These tutorials will present some of the basic tools and techniques involved in creating captions for Google Video, YouTube, and other Flash-based video hosting providers, as well as provide more advanced tips and techniques for creating Timed Text XML files, which can be used with the Adobe Flash® and Microsoft Silverlight® video players. Feel free to read through the tutorials and then check out DCMP’s list of CIY resources to pick the best tool(s) for your needs.
Bear in mind that none of these free captioning sites and tools will make it possible to create captions which conform to the DCMP Captioning Key. Creating captions with the proper font style, color, and placement characteristics required to meet the Captioning Key’s rigorous guidelines involves more extensive tools and techniques than those covered here. As streaming video player caption technologies continue to evolve, the DCMP will provide more information and tutorials on our site to assist parents, educators, and others in creating “DCMP Approved” captions to benefit learners of all ages and abilities.
Guidelines for Captions
It is important that the captions be (1) synchronized and appear at approximately the same time as the audio is available; (2) verbatim when time allows, or as close as possible; (3) equivalent and equal in content; and (4) accessible and readily available to those who need or want them.
The most important thing about captions and subtitles is that, when they appear on the screen, they are in an easy-to-read format. Currently available methods of captioning Web content vary in their capabilities, but good captions adhere to the following guidelines when possible:
- Captions appear on-screen long enough to be read.
- It is preferable to limit on-screen captions to no more than two lines.
- Captions are synchronized with spoken words.
- Speakers should be identified when more than one person is on-screen or when the speaker is not visible.
- Punctuation is used to clarify meaning.
- Spelling is correct throughout the production.
- Sound effects are written when they add to understanding.
- All actual words are captioned, regardless of language or dialect.
- Use of slang and accent is preserved and identified.
If the captioning tool permits, teachers will want to remember
- Nouns and verbs are not separated from their modifiers.
- Prepositional phrases remain on the same line.
- Italics is effective when a new word is being defined or a word is heavily emphasized in speech.
- Translating speech to text sometimes requires creative use of punctuation, but always remember the rules of good grammar.
The above are very abbreviated guidelines for quick captioning of your videos of field trips, classroom experiences, and other activities. To explore preferred captioning techniques in greater detail, visit our Captioning Key.